I already paid the sextortionist $500 and they're asking for more — what do I do
Paid a sextortion demand and now facing escalating payment requests
You paid. You thought it would make them stop. Now they want more. Maybe $200 became $500, or $500 became $2,000. You're terrified, you feel trapped, and you're wondering if this will ever end.
It will end. But not by paying more. The single most important thing you can do right now is stop sending money. Not another dollar. The cycle of escalation only stops when you cut off the supply.1
Every payment confirms you as a viable target. The FBI reports that paying sextortionists leads to increased demands in the vast majority of cases. You will never buy your way out of this.
Why Paying Makes It Worse
This is counterintuitive because in every other area of life, paying to resolve a problem makes sense. But sextortion doesn't work that way. Here's the economics from the criminal's perspective:
Sextortion operations categorize targets. Unpaid targets get abandoned. Paid targets get escalated — because they've proven they can be extracted from.
The scammer has no incentive to honor any deal. You have no enforcement mechanism. Every payment just resets the clock on the next demand.
Criminal networks share lists of paying victims. Your contact info, payment history, and leverage material may be sold to a new operator who starts the cycle again.
Your Recovery Plan (Starting Right Now)
Block their number, their social media accounts, and any email addresses they've used. Do not explain why you're blocking them — just do it.
Before blocking, screenshot every conversation, every payment receipt, every platform they contacted you through. Save transaction IDs from Cash App, Venmo, Zelle, or crypto transfers.
Go to ic3.gov and file a detailed complaint. Include all payment amounts, methods, and transaction IDs. Include the scammer's usernames, phone numbers, and any other identifying information.
Report the recipient account on Cash App, Venmo, or whatever payment method you used. These platforms have fraud teams that can flag and sometimes freeze scammer accounts.
Set everything to private. Remove follower/following lists from public view. This cuts off the scammer's access to your contacts if they try to reach you through a new account.
If you paid via bank transfer, contact your bank immediately about a fraud claim. Credit card payments may be reversible through chargebacks. Cash App and Venmo payments are generally not recoverable.
After you stop paying, the scammer will likely escalate their threats — "last chance," "sending to your mom in 24 hours," etc. This is the desperation phase. They want one more payment before giving up. Most scammers abandon non-paying targets within 1-2 weeks.
Can You Get Your Money Back?
Honestly? Probably not. But it's worth trying:
Cash App / Venmo / Zelle: These platforms treat transfers as peer-to-peer transactions and generally don't offer buyer protection. File a fraud report anyway — it helps their teams identify and ban scammer accounts.
Credit card: If you made a payment via credit card, you may be able to initiate a chargeback. Contact your card issuer and explain the payment was made under duress/extortion.
Cryptocurrency: Bitcoin and other crypto payments are effectively unrecoverable. However, include the wallet addresses in your FBI report — law enforcement has gotten better at tracing crypto.
Wire transfer / gift cards: Unfortunately, these are almost always unrecoverable.
What Happens After You Stop Paying
The first few days will be the hardest. The scammer may send more threatening messages through new accounts, increase the urgency, or claim they've started distributing your images. Here's the typical timeline:2
The scammer throws everything they have at you. More urgent deadlines, specific threats about family members, screenshots of your contacts. This is the blitz — designed to break your resolve.
Messages become less frequent. They may try different platforms or phone numbers. Continue blocking without responding.
Most scammers give up within two weeks. Some make one final "last chance" attempt around the 10-day mark. Do not respond.
The overwhelming majority of sextortion operations move on to new targets after two weeks of no response. Continue monitoring but the acute threat has passed.
“I paid $800 total over three rounds. Each time I paid, they demanded more within 48 hours. When I finally stopped and blocked them — nothing happened. Two weeks of silence and it was over. I wish I'd stopped after the first demand.”
— Reddit, r/Sextortion survivor
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources & Citations
- 1FBI advisory: Sextortion victims who pay are overwhelmingly targeted with additional demands. The FBI advises against paying. FBI.gov ↗
- 2Thorn research on sextortion timelines and scammer behavior patterns after victim non-payment. Thorn ↗
- 3FBI Internet Crime Report 2023: Sextortion complaints and reported financial losses exceeded $12.5 billion total for all IC3 categories. FBI IC3 ↗
We Can Handle This For You
Prevent This From Happening Again
Ongoing monitoring and protection
People Also Asked
Still need help?
Talk to Our Team →