Expunged charge still appearing — lost rental and job opportunity
Sealed or expunged records still showing in searches and background checks
You did everything right. Went through the legal process, paid the fees, waited the months, and got your record expunged. The court says it never happened. But mugshot sites, background check companies, and Google still say otherwise — and it just cost you a rental application.
This is not supposed to happen, and it may be illegal. Background check companies that report expunged records are violating the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and you may be entitled to damages.1 But getting the information actually removed requires action on multiple fronts.
Courts can seal your record from official databases, but they have no authority over private websites, data brokers, or Google. The gap between legal expungement and digital reality is the problem you need to solve.
Why Expunged Records Keep Appearing
Sites like BustedMugshots and Arrests.org scrape court databases daily. Once they have your booking photo, they don't automatically check for later expungements.
Companies like Checkr, Sterling, and LexisNexis update on different schedules. Your expungement may not have reached their records yet — or ever, if no one notifies them.
Google cached the mugshot sites and court record pages. Even after the original page is removed, Google's index entry can persist for months.
Spokeo, BeenVerified, and similar sites buy court record data in bulk. They don't sync with expungement orders.
How to Force Removal
Step 1: Background Check Companies
Under the FCRA, background check companies must maintain accurate records and investigate disputes within 30 days.2 Send your expungement order directly to every major provider:
Contact the court clerk and request multiple certified copies. You'll need to send them to multiple companies.
Contact Checkr, Sterling, GoodHire, HireRight, and LexisNexis directly. Include the expungement order and a dispute letter stating the record must be removed.
The FCRA requires investigation within 30 days. If the record still appears, you have grounds for an FCRA lawsuit.
Step 2: Mugshot Sites
Send your expungement order to each mugshot site hosting your record. Many states have laws requiring mugshot sites to remove expunged records free of charge. If a site charges you for removal of an expunged record, they may be violating state law.
Step 3: Google
Once the source pages are removed, submit Google cache removal requests through the "Remove outdated content" tool. Google also accepts removal requests for arrest records associated with expunged cases.
Your Legal Rights After Expungement
FCRA violations: A background check company that reports an expunged record can be sued for statutory damages of $100-$1,000 per violation, plus actual damages and attorney fees. Many FCRA attorneys work on contingency.
State mugshot laws: At least 18 states prohibit mugshot sites from charging for removal. Several require free removal upon proof of expungement.
Employment rights: In most states, you can legally deny the arrest ever occurred on job applications after expungement. For a comprehensive approach, a criminal record removal service can address all of these fronts simultaneously.
Background check companies would rather pay a settlement than litigate. Many cases settle for $3,000-$10,000 without going to trial. An FCRA attorney can evaluate your case in a free consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources & Citations
- 1National Consumer Law Center: Background checks and the FCRA — rights of individuals with expunged or sealed records. NCLC ↗
- 2Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) Section 611: Consumer dispute process requiring investigation within 30 days. FTC Consumer Information ↗
- 3Collateral Consequences Resource Center: State-by-state guide to expungement and record sealing eligibility. CCRC ↗
We Can Handle This For You
Prevent This From Happening Again
Ongoing monitoring and protection
People Also Asked
Still need help?
Talk to Our Team →